Peter Rost vs. Pfizer: The DOJ Is Back

3 Comments

peterrosttwo.jpg

In a boost to Peter Rost, the pharmacetical gadfly, the Justice Department is seeking permission to have until April 26 to file a friend-of-the-court brief in a qui tam, or whistleblower case he brought against Pfizer. Rost charged Pfizer - and Pharmacia, his former employer, which Pfizer acquired - with violating the False Claims Act by off-label promotion of Genotropin, a growth hormone treatment for which he had been responsible.

For those with good memories, Rost’s claim was denied last year by a federal court judge in Boston. Before that, the US Attorney in Boston declined to join his case. So why is the Justice Department getting involved now? The reason cited by the judge for denying the claim was that Rost failed to show harm to a single patient, which is quite difficult to do in an age of tightening privacy laws. By taking that view, the judge may have made it very difficult for the US Attorney in Boston, which is successfully chasing drugmakers for off-label activities, to file additional charges under the federal False Claims Act.

“Resolution of this case could have a substantial impact on the Act’s jurisdictional bar and the pleading requirements for complaints brought under the False Claims Act,” the DOJ writes in its motion, which refers to the “importance of the legal issues raised by this case.” By seeking extra time, the DOJ hopes to convince the US Solicitor General to pursue the matter and file a friend-of-the-court-brief to accompany the appeal Rost filed the other day.

This occurs just as the scandal breaks over White House interference with US Attorneys, suggesting the decision may provide clues about the extent to which the DOJ will be committed to pursuing corporate fraud. Now, Pharmalot understands why Rost, who recently restarted his blog, looked so happy two days ago during a chance meeting in a Borders book store.

“Something wonderful is happening,” he cackled. Well, not for Pfizer.

Pharmalot has the DOJ motion and will provide a link as soon as possible.[tags]False Claims Act, Genotropin, Off-Label Marketing, Peter Rost, Pfizer, Pharmacia[/tags]

Jump to comments

Share

Comments

  1. This really is good news for Doc.Peter but far better news for the people. If all those big pharma that do these things routinelly( not only in USA where they can really get trouble) everywhere to expand use of their drugs beyond the approved indications or to grab more market share on the backs of others, get thier wings clipped, we all will be better off for it.
    Does anyone don’t agree???

  2. There are so few who are willing to speak up for the voiceless masses. “Doing the right thing” –perhaps because it is so seldom done?–deserves headlines. It will be interesting to see if the judiciary is willing “to do the right thing.” Or, wil they abdicate their responsibility and make “justice for all” merely an anachronistic ideal?

  3. Well, it ain’t a done deal. The US Solicitor General has to say okay, or words to that effect. But the fact that the DOJ took this step is quite interesting.

    ed

Subscribe

RSS Feed

Comments feed for this post only.

Tags

, , , , ,

Clear

Clear

© 2007- 2008 Newark Morning Ledger Co.  All Rights Reserved.

Thanks for trying out the new Pharmalot printing tools. If you're got any suggestions for how we can help you print better, please let us know by clicking on the contact link at http://www.pharmalot.com/

-->